A Collection of Strange Beliefs, Amusing Deceptions, and Dangerous Delusions

From Abracadabra to Zombies | View All

pyramid scheme

A pyramid scheme is a fraudulent system of making money which requires an endless stream of recruits for success. Recruits (a) give money to recruiters and (b) enlist fresh recruits to give them money.

A pyramid scheme is called a pyramid scheme because of the shape of a pyramid: a three dimensional triangle. If a pyramid were started by a human being at the top with just 10 people beneath him, and 100 beneath them, and 1000 beneath them, etc., the pyramid would involve everyone on earth in just ten layers of people with one con man on top. The human pyramid would be about 60 feet high and the bottom layer would have more than 4.5 billion people!

A diagram might help see this:

1
10
100
1,000
10,000
100,000
1,000,000
10,000,000
100,000,000
1,000,000,000
10,000,000,000

Thus, in very short order, 10 recruiting 10 and so on would reach 10 billion, well in excess of the earth's population. If the entire population of earth were 5 billion and we all got involved in a pyramid scheme, the bottom layer would consist of about 90 percent of the planet, i.e., about 4.5 billion people. Thus, for 500 million people to be WINNERS, 4.5 billion must be LOSERS.

In a straightforward pyramid scheme, a recruit is asked to give a sum of money, say $100, to a recruiter. The new recruit then enlists, say, 10 more recruits, to give up $100 each. In the simplest example, the recruiter keeps all the money he gets from his recruits. In our example, each recruit gives up $100 in exchange for $900 ($100 from each of his 10 recruits minus the $100 he gave his own recruiter). In order for no one to lose money, the recruiting must go on forever. On a planet with a limited number of people, even if the planet is as large as Earth and has more than 6 billion potential recruits, one runs out of new recruits rather quickly.

Thus, the result of all these schemes is inevitable: at best, a few people walk away with a lot of money, while most recruits lose whatever money they put into the scheme. In fact, the only way anybody can make money through a pyramid scheme or chain letter is if other people are defrauded into giving money upon a promise of getting something in return when it will be impossible for them to get anything at all in return. That is to say, in plain English, these schemes always constitute fraud. They use deception to get money. That is why they are illegal. They are not illegal because they involve recruiting people to recruit other people to recruit other people. That is perfectly legal and is done to some degree in many legitimate businesses. They are not illegal because they involve giving money to people. It is perfectly legal to give money to people. They are illegal because they involve deceiving people in order to get money from them: that is the legal meaning of fraud.

In actual fact, however, no pyramid scheme will ever work this way because the scheme will never get the number of recruits we've been speculating about. All pyramid schemes will begin to die when the later recruits don't sign on in numbers large enough to pay off the earlier recruits. There will always be enough people who will smell the scheme out. There will always be too many people who will say "if it sounds too good to be true that's probably because it is." There may even be a good number of people who will realize that though one person recruiting ten doesn't sound like much, it quickly adds up to unrealistic and improbable numbers. Also, all it takes is one person to stop the whole thing, either by adamantly persuading recruiters of their indecency, or by reporting them to the police.

greed and wishful thinking

Pyramid schemes are popular because people are greedy and greed can do wonders to a person's thinking. For a person desiring to make a lot of money from a small investment in a short amount of time, wishful thinking often takes over where critical thinking should step in. Wishes become facts. Skeptics become idiots for not getting on board. Desires become reality. Asking questions seems rude and unfriendly. Scam artists know how greed works and all it takes is one con man to get the thing started.

With the odds so stacked against a person, why would one gamble on a pyramid scheme? Greed is only part of the answer. Most pyramid people don't envision themselves anywhere near the bottom layer of the pyramid. Even the most greedy person on the planet would probably see that if one is near the bottom layer of recruits it will be very hard to get new recruits. They have to see themselves near the top in order to envision the immense wealth from minimal effort that is going to come their way.

Furthermore, if I hope to get people involved in a pyramid scheme, the first thing I must do is convince them they are not getting involved in a pyramid scheme. They may know they are illegal. Or they may realize that pyramid schemes are a losing proposition for at least 90 percent of those who get involved. So, I tell them they are joining a club. I give the club a nice name such as The Friendly Investors Club (FIC). I reassure them that the FIC is approved by the IRS and run by a CPA with a Ph.D. who is not an ASS. If I'm really good, my recruits will believe me and the police officers, secretaries, teachers, ministers, etc. whom I recruit. These well-respected, intelligent, honest people will pass on this line to others. If I am really, really good, I will have convinced my recruits not only that they are getting into a legitimate and lucrative Club, but that any earnings are tax-free. I would indicate to recruits that as long as their take in the scheme is less than $10,000, it wouldn't be taxable because gifts aren't taxable until they exceed $10,000. I would convince the recruits that, for legal purposes, they would be giving money away and others would be giving money to them.

even the police like pyramid schemes

In 1995-96, at least 67 employees of the Sacramento Police Department, including 45 officers, were investigated for their alleged involvement in a pyramid scheme (Sacramento Bee 10/28/95, 11/1/95 and 11/15 & 16/96). The scheme was similar to five others that had been operating in southern California, also involving police officers and support staff. The main suspect in the Sacramento scheme was a police captain's wife. The chief of police said that he would try to fire at least seven officers and discipline 60 other police department employees. Nine officers were placed on administrative leave and relieved of their guns and badges. According to a prosecutor, the scheme involved more than 200 people. However, only three of the accused faced criminal misdemeanor charges. Reportedly, some in the scheme made tens of thousands of dollars. The minimum amount lost by those who were on the bottom of the pyramid was $500.

The police pyramid schemes are called "investment clubs" and have attractive names such as "The Friendship Investment Club" and "A Gift Network." They're sold to investors with the assurance that they are perfectly legal, approved by the IRS or a CPA, and that they definitely are not a pyramid scheme.

The Sacramento scheme was called The Freedom Club or something like that. And it was hyped by a police officer as being legal because it required people to sign a waiver claiming that they were making an unconditional gift to the Freedom Club. A local news reporter, Mike Boyd, asked an IRS agent if this waiver meant the Freedom Club wasn't a pyramid scheme. The IRS agent said that since the people who were signing the waiver expected to get back money for the money they were allegedly making a gift of, the money wasn't really a gift. An attorney, also interviewed by Boyd, agreed that just signing a paper saying you're making an unconditional gift didn't make it so if your intention was not to make an unconditional gift. (Receiving gifts, of course, is legal, and tax free.) The cops and their recruits for the Freedom Club put in at least $500 each and expected something like $4,000 in return for their phony gifts, according to Boyd. The Bee reported that sources told them that some Police Department personnel got more than $10,000 out of the scheme. The WINNERS in the scheme got their money from "gifts" to the Freedom Club from those who later joined the Club. Such schemes continue, if the participants are not caught, until there are not enough new recruits to pay off the old ones. That is, they would continue until there were a good number of people who had "given" away $500 and got nothing in return because the scheme folded. The scheme would have to fold eventually, because there can't be an endless stream of recruits.

The Sacramento Police Pyramid scheme involved what we might call "pyramid pods". An organizer (Numero Uno) would start the pod by getting six others to join as organizers. Presumably, the six would be ranked depending on when they were recruited. The organizers pay nothing to join the pod but together they must recruit enough people into the pod to buy eight spots at the bottom of their pyramid. Each spot costs $500. Numero Uno pockets the $4,000. The pod splits into two pods of seven people (or spots) each, with a new Numero Uno in each pod (and a new number 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 and 7). Each pyramid pod recruits more people at $500 for each of eight spots in the pyramid. The two new Numero Unos take their $4,000 each and the two pods split into 4 pods and those 4 into 16, ad infinitum. To make even more money, some joined more than one pod.

How many in this scheme told the new recruits that 6.7% of those who join will get a 700% return on their investment ($3,500 on a $500 investment) as long as 93.3% get nothing? How many advised their recruits to "get in early"?

To have police involved adds a special dimension to this pyramid scheme because (a) officers have ranks and can use their rank for recruiting leverage over those beneath them; (b) officers and ex-officers have positions of authority and trust which may influence potential recruits; and (c) police personnel are supposed to enforce the law. When the law enforcers become lawbreakers and encourage others to break the law for monetary gain, respect for law and law officers diminishes.

People who are members of an identifiable group, such as church members or members of the same race or ethnic group, are especially vulnerable to fraudulent investment schemes brought to them by one of their own (or one who claims to be one of their own). Affinity fraud takes advantage of the trust that members have for others in their group, especially for those who are considered leaders. Professionals, the elderly, teachers, and other groups have been victims of affinity fraud. Some examples include: Waldorf School teachers, Jehovah's Witnesses, African-American Baptists, Indian Fijians, and senior citizens.

See also Amway, chain letter, multi-level marketing, multi-Level marketing harassment, Ponzi scheme, and my review of False Profits - Seeking Financial and Spiritual Deliverance in Multi-Level Marketing and Pyramid Schemes by Robert L. Fitzpatrick and Joyce Reynolds (Charlotte, N.C.: Herald Press, 1997).

reader comments

further reading

books and articles

Bulgatz, Joseph. Ponzi Schemes, Invaders From Mars, and More Extraordinary Popular Delusions (Harmony Books, 1992). out of print

Fitzpatrick, Robert L. and Joyce Reynolds. False Profits - Seeking Financial and Spiritual Deliverance in Multi-Level Marketing and Pyramid Schemes (Charlotte, N.C.: Herald Press, 1997). See my review of this book.

Walsh, James. You Can't Cheat an Honest Man: How Ponzi Schemes and Pyramid Frauds Work... and Why They're More Common Than Ever (Merritt Publishing, 1998).

websites

Pyramid Scheme Alert "The international spread of pyramid schemes, often perpetrated by individuals or companies based in the USA, will be a special focus of Pyramid Scheme Alert."

Read about Fortuna Alliance and the FTC charges that it is a pyramid scheme being run on the internet!

17 in 100 Adults Involved in Multi-Level Marketing Korea Times/November 25, 2003 By Kim Sung-jin

Pyramid Schemes, Ponzi Schemes, and Related Frauds by Bob Blaylock

The Bottom Line About Multilevel Marketing Plans - FTC

"Tips on....Multi-Level Marketing (How to Tell a Legitimate Opportunity from a Pyramid Scheme)"

Those Thrilling Days (about the Fortuna scam)

Another press release from the Seattle Regional Office

news

Little Bernie Madoffs Abound on the Internet; BBB Warns Cash Gifting Pyramid Schemes Flourishing Online (Better Business Bureau warns that cash gifting is not a legitimate way to make a few extra dollars, and in fact, is nothing more than a pyramid scheme....According to TubeMogul, an online video analytics company, currently there are 22,974 “cash gifting” videos on YouTube, adding up to an astounding 59,192,963 views.)


Last updated 12/09/10

© Copyright 1994-2013 Robert T. Carroll * This page was designed by Cristian Popa.